South Africa Vs Scotland: Match Player Ratings

Nuigalway Admin

You need 4 min read

·

Post on Nov 11, 2024

46 visitor like this post

Share

South Africa vs Scotland: Match Player Ratings - Springboks Dominate in Edinburgh

The Springboks roared into Edinburgh and delivered a dominant performance, securing a comfortable 30-15 victory over Scotland. The South Africans showcased their strength and experience, leaving the Scots struggling to find their rhythm throughout the match. Here's a breakdown of the player ratings from a thrilling encounter:

South Africa:

• Damian Willemse (9/10): A standout performer, Willemse orchestrated the Springboks' attack with precision and composure. His pinpoint kicks and ability to break the line with pace and power were key to South Africa's success.
• Makazole Mapimpi (8/10): The winger was a constant threat on the wing, scoring a try and proving a nightmare for the Scottish defense. His speed and finishing prowess were on full display.
• Pieter-Steph du Toit (8/10): A relentless force in the back row, du Toit dominated the breakdown and provided crucial support to the forwards. His work rate and physicality were a constant source of pressure on the Scottish team.
• Handré Pollard (7.5/10): The fly-half controlled the game effectively with his kicking and tactical decisions. He landed crucial penalties and controlled the tempo with his precise distribution.
• Malcolm Marx (7.5/10): The hooker was a constant nuisance at the scrum, providing a strong platform for the Springboks' attack. He also contributed to the lineout with his sharp throws.
• Eben Etzebeth (7/10): The lock was a dominant force in the lineout and set the tone with his aggressive defense. His physical presence was a key factor in South Africa's dominance.
• Kurt-Lee Arendse (7/10): The winger was a lively presence on the pitch, offering pace and a willingness to chase kicks. He also showed good awareness in defense.
• Bongi Mbonambi (6.5/10): The hooker was effective in the set pieces and added valuable contributions in the loose play.
• Steven Kitshoff (6.5/10): A solid performance from the prop, who provided stability in the scrum and made vital contributions around the field.
• Jasper Wiese (6.5/10): The flanker was a busy presence in the back row, tackling strongly and providing cover in defense.
• Franco Mostert (6/10): The flanker contributed to the dominant performance with his work rate and commitment to the breakdown.
• Lukhanyo Am (6/10): The center was a steady presence in the midfield, offering support to the attack and covering well in defense.
• Jesse Kriel (6/10): The center was a reliable presence in the midfield, tackling strongly and supporting the attack.
• Canan Moodie (5/10): The winger had a mixed performance, showing glimpses of promise but struggling to make a significant impact.
• Frans Malherbe (5/10): The prop was solid in the scrum but struggled to make a major impact outside of the set pieces.

Scotland:

• Finn Russell (7/10): The fly-half was Scotland's best player, showing flashes of brilliance with his passing and kicking skills. However, he was often hampered by the lack of support around him.
• Stuart Hogg (6.5/10): The fullback was a threat in attack, showing his trademark pace and evasiveness. However, he was let down by some poor decision-making at times.
• Hamish Watson (6.5/10): The flanker was a tireless worker in the back row, tackling strongly and attempting to disrupt the Springboks' momentum.
• Rory Sutherland (6/10): The prop was a solid performer in the scrum, but struggled to make a significant impact outside of the set pieces.
• Matt Fagerson (6/10): The number eight provided some strong carries and was a key figure in the breakdown for Scotland.
• Ben White (5.5/10): The lock struggled to contain the Springboks' physicality and struggled to make a significant impact in the lineout.
• Grant Gilchrist (5.5/10): The lock faced a difficult battle against the powerful South African forwards and struggled to establish himself in the lineout.
• Zander Fagerson (5.5/10): The prop was solid in the scrum but failed to make a major impact outside of the set pieces.
• Sam Johnson (5/10): The center struggled to penetrate the strong South African defense and was unable to provide much support to the attack.
• Chris Harris (5/10): The center offered some tackles and carries but failed to make a significant impact on the game.
• Duhan van der Merwe (5/10): The winger was unable to find space against the strong Springboks defense and struggled to make an impact.
• Blair Kinghorn (5/10): The fullback was a shadow of his former self, making some errors and struggling to impact the game.
• Ali Price (4.5/10): The scrum-half struggled to control the tempo and make a positive impact on the game.
• Jonny Gray (4.5/10): The flanker was unable to replicate his previous performances and failed to make a significant impact on the game.
• George Turner (4.5/10): The hooker struggled to make an impact in the set pieces and failed to contribute much in the loose play.

Conclusion:

South Africa delivered a dominant performance, showcasing their strength and experience. The Springboks' power, discipline, and tactical awareness were key to their success. While Scotland showed glimpses of brilliance, their overall performance was hampered by individual errors and their inability to match the intensity of the Springboks. The South Africans will undoubtedly be looking to build on this victory as they continue their international campaign.